Mosaic

Via What It Is Today, a mosaic of the soldiers who have been killed in Iraq. I might bring it into class when we talk about visual arguments. It's a provocative image, raising such obvious questions as: Is it too simplistic? Is it exploitative? Is it ethical to use all of these soldiers' faces? Many of them were likely earnest supporters of the war. What questions at issue and arguments does it raise about why we're at war?

Edited to move image to the "read more" area.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Another question

Are the photos PhotoShopped, because otherwise how are some of them so white for the color?

And if they are, is that ethical?

--
http://deann.blogspot.com

Link

I wonder if it would play any differently if the large image was clickable image map that allowed you to see full-size versions of the originals.

All Day Permanent Red

Mosaic

I guess it would depend upon the context in which the mosaic is viewed.

It seems manipulative, and in a way, it very obviously is, simply by way of the effort gone into it. I don't like things that conjure images and feelings, particularly political ones, without using words. I realize that imagery and subconscious connotations and how it affects viewers emotionally are a combined cornerstone for the practices of politicians and a great number of marketers within the business of America, but I've never quite shaken the opinion that all that shit is nothing but yellow journalistic practice, and just because everyone else is doing it, never makes it right. I think it is exploitive because there is no indication that any of the soldiers whose photos are used would support the inherent message being presented, and of course, there's no indication because there's no explanation, just the photo, as noted.

In clicking on the link to What is it Today, I see that the blogger rec'd it via email, which seems quite the appropriate forum.

  • Login to post comments
  • Oops

    Sigh - sorry, that was me, forgot to sign.

    Michelle

    Comment viewing options

    Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.